Since the answer to the question in the title is not exceedingly complicated, let’s focus on something more twisted before moving into the whole process of ‘how’ to be a tragic hero- Should you be a tragic hero at all? Hopefully, the answer to this question will aid in a greater understanding of the second.
So, should you be tragic hero in the 21st Century?
Greenday’s 2004 album ‘American Idiot’ had a central figure called the Jesus of Suburbia who was torn into choosing between St. Jimmy and Whatsername. The hero is plagued by the typical modernist discontent where he does not really like where he was born so he leaves the city in the search of something to believe in. Quite predictably, a person raised on “soda pop and Ritalin” cannot hope for more sophisticated options to choose from when he faces a crossroad, than St. Jimmy, who represents “rebellion and self-destruction” and Whatsername, who represents “following your beliefs and ethics.” The tragedy of this hero lies in the fact that even though he chooses the latter and the better option, in the final song of the album, it is revealed that he has not only lost contact with Whatsername but cannot even remember what she was called. The ending is quite post-modernist.
Now, these are the reasons why you should not really want to be like the Jesus of Suburbia or for that matter, any tragic hero at all, in whichever century you live in:
Tragic heroes are known for their maladjustment to the society; and while a hero like this is a socially conscious writer’s dream, the heroes themselves don’t seem to be very happy with their lives. The problem with this is that everyone else in that age isn’t really very unhappy. To have a disillusioned generation of people is one thing, but tragic heroes like this are always very isolated people in whichever era that they belong to.
For example, Jimmy Porter in ‘Look Back in Anger’ may represent the Angry Young Generation but he has no one to actually confide in. You can be angry and you may have many things to say, things that no one understands, but isolating yourself further and putting yourself on a pedestal to overcome that grinding feeling that you are not enough, is not a solution. If someone had simply told Jimmy, “Yes, I know that you are pissed off with the world and so am I, let’s not keep shouting at each other because I understand you,” that may or may not have worked. Jimmy loved complaining so he may not have stopped even after that, but since one of the major reasons why he complained was that no one ever tried to understand him, perhaps taking away that excuse would put a stop to that.
After all, these modern heroes don’t seem to understand that whatever they are facing, hundreds of others are facing too. It’s not really about sensitivity as they keep telling us. Everyone has their own demons. Everyone is isolated. And since everyone is isolated- no one should feel too isolated. Yes Prufrock, they don’t understand your problems but you don’t understand theirs either, do you?
I am not telling people to not be J. Alfred Prufrock or Jesus of Suburbia or Jimmy Porter or Hamlet or Macbeth. People remember them, yes, but only in writing. In the real world, these people lead pointlessly miserable lives when they can just come out of their bubble of seclusion and try to understand others’ point of views to have their own understood. To put it simply, those works should come with a “Don’t try this in real life” warning.
To round this up, I need to answer the question that I started with- How to be a Tragic Hero?
- Be very discontented with your life.
- Don’t fit in.
- Have a problem that many other people face but then make a huge deal about it.
- Complain about others being insensitive to your issues when you are just as insensitive to their issues.
- At least manage to inspire ONE poet or writer because if you are not immortalized as a piece of literature even after going through all that shit for no reason, when you could have led a perfectly good life, it was all in vain.